Best Pot for Making Pickles: What’s Safe for Brine, What’s Not, and Why Advice Conflicts

This post contains affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

If you’ve searched for the best pot for making pickles, you’ve probably seen three different answers: “use stainless steel,” “never use stainless,” and “aluminum is fine.” They can all be partly right, because heating a pickling liquid is a different job from holding vegetables in brine for days or weeks. Most guides lump the two together. This one separates them, using two university extension services, so you know which pot goes on the stove and which container the cucumbers sit in.

This is general kitchen guidance. For safe pickling, always follow a tested recipe, and see your extension service’s instructions for processing times.

Two Jobs, Two Containers

Pickling usually involves two kinds of vessel:

  1. A pot to heat the pickling liquid (vinegar, water, salt and spices) for a short time.
  2. A container to hold the vegetables in brine for longer, such as when you ferment cucumbers or cabbage.

University of Missouri Extension draws exactly this line. It says that over time, pitting can occur if foods are brined or pickled in stainless steel containers, and that the salt, not the vinegar, causes it. So it is best to brine in a stone crock, food-grade plastic, glass or unchipped enamelware. But it adds that it is fine to heat pickling liquids in a stainless steel pot, because the liquid is in the pot for only a short time.

So stainless is fine on the stove, and it’s less ideal as a long-term brining vessel.

Choosing a Pot for Making Pickles

For heating pickling liquid, University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension’s equipment list says to use unchipped enamelware, stainless steel, aluminum or glass pots. That list is one reason you’ll see conflicting advice online. Some canning blogs say to avoid aluminum with vinegar. The Nebraska list includes it for short heating. Missouri’s page doesn’t mention aluminum.

Here is how to read that:

MaterialHeating pickling liquidNotes
Stainless steelYes, per Missouri and NebraskaFine for the stove. Missouri says it’s not ideal for long brining because salt can pit it
Unchipped enamelwareYes, per NebraskaMissouri lists it for brining too. If it’s chipped, don’t use it
Glass potYes, per NebraskaNeeds a heat source it can handle
AluminumListed as acceptable by NebraskaSome canning blogs advise against it. If you’d rather avoid the debate, use stainless or enamel
Copper, brass, iron, galvanizedNoNebraska says not to use copper, brass, iron or galvanized utensils

Nebraska’s warning on those metals is direct: they “may react with acids or salts and cause undesirable color and flavors,” and may form toxic compounds in the pickle mixture. That is why bare cast iron isn’t on the list. Enameled cast iron has an enamel surface, so it falls under “unchipped enamelware” as long as the enamel is intact. (That connection is our reading of the list, not a line from either extension page.)

If you don’t know whether to trust an older pot, the safest bet is a stainless steel pot, which no source objects to for heating pickling liquid. Our nonstick vs. stainless steel guide explains how stainless differs from other surfaces.

👉 Browse stainless steel stock pots with lids

Why Chipped Enamel Is a Problem Here

Both extension pages say enamelware only counts when it is unchipped. That matters for pickling because a chip exposes the metal underneath to the acid and salt. If you’re not sure about an old enamel pot, our chipped enamel Dutch oven guide explains where chips matter and what to do about them.

What to Ferment or Brine In

If you’re making fermented pickles or sauerkraut, the container matters more than the pot. Nebraska Extension gives specific guidance:

  • Size: a 1-gallon container for each 5 pounds of fresh vegetables. A 5-gallon stone crock is the ideal size for fermenting about 25 pounds of cabbage or cucumbers.
  • Material: food-grade plastic and glass containers are excellent substitutes for stone crocks.
  • Other plastic: 1- to 3-gallon non-food-grade plastic containers may be used if lined with a clean food-grade plastic bag.
  • Mason jars: fermenting in quart and half-gallon jars is acceptable but may cause more spoilage losses.
  • Keeping vegetables under the brine: Nebraska suggests a suitably sized dinner plate or glass pie plate inside the container, weighed down with 2 to 3 sealed quart jars filled with water.
  • Cover: a clean, heavy bath towel over the opening helps prevent contamination.

👉 Browse glass fermentation jars with weights

👉 Browse stoneware fermenting crocks

What About Processing the Jars?

Heating the brine and processing the filled jars are separate steps, and each uses a different pot. The canner is a different pot with its own rules. Our water bath canning pot guide covers it, and our jam pot guide covers the cooking pot for preserves.

If you’re sizing a pot for a big batch of brine, our stock pot sizing guide shows what common pot sizes hold.

A Simple Pickling Setup

  • A stainless steel or unchipped enamel pot to heat the pickling liquid
  • A stone crock, glass jar or food-grade plastic container if you ferment, sized at 1 gallon per 5 pounds of vegetables
  • A plate and weights to keep vegetables under the brine
  • Utensils that aren’t copper, brass, iron or galvanized
  • A canner for processing jars (see our canning guide)

Mistakes to Avoid

  • Using a chipped enamel pot. The extension lists only unchipped enamelware.
  • Brining for days in a stainless pot. Missouri Extension says salt can pit it over time.
  • Using copper, brass, iron or galvanized utensils. Nebraska says they can react with acids and salts.
  • Skipping the plate and weights. Nebraska Extension includes them in its fermenting setup.
  • Guessing at the salt. Missouri says to measure salt and water carefully to get the right salt concentration.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best pot for making pickles? Stainless steel or unchipped enamelware is the safest pick for heating pickling liquid. Both are on the extension lists.

Can you use an aluminum pot for pickling? Nebraska Extension lists aluminum as acceptable for heating pickling liquids. Some canning blogs advise against it, so use stainless or enamel if you want to avoid the question.

Can you use cast iron for pickles? Bare iron isn’t recommended. Nebraska says not to use copper, brass, iron or galvanized utensils. Enameled cast iron with intact enamel is enamelware.

Can you brine pickles in a stainless steel pot? For heating, yes. For long brining, Missouri Extension says pitting can occur over time and recommends a stone crock, food-grade plastic, glass or unchipped enamelware.

What size container do I need to ferment cucumbers? One gallon for each 5 pounds of vegetables, per Nebraska Extension.

Can I ferment pickles in a Mason jar? Nebraska says quart and half-gallon jars are acceptable but may cause more spoilage losses.


The right pot for making pickles is a stainless steel or unchipped enamel pot for the brine, and a crock, glass or food-grade container for anything that sits for days. For tested recipes and equipment lists, read University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension’s “Home Canning Equipment for Making Pickles” and University of Missouri Extension’s “Packing perfect pickles”, two solid, non-commercial resources worth reading.


Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment